Article 17 of the EU Copyright Directive makes certain upload platforms directly responsible for copyright infringement in what their users post. If your site counts as an "online content-sharing service provider" (OCSSP), you cannot simply rely on the hosting safe harbour: you must make best efforts to obtain licences from rights holders, best efforts to keep notified works off the site, and act quickly on notices. Platforms that do this are not liable for unlicensed uploads; platforms that do not, are.

For adult tube sites, clip stores with user uploads and other video-sharing services targeting the EU, this is one of the most important pieces of copyright law to understand. This article is general information, not legal advice.

What Article 17 of the DSM Directive does

The Directive on Copyright in the Digital Single Market (EU) 2019/790, usually called the DSM Directive, had to be transposed into national law by 7 June 2021. Article 17 changes the default position for one category of service:

  • When an OCSSP gives the public access to copyright works uploaded by its users, the platform itself is treated as communicating those works to the public.
  • So it needs authorisation from rights holders, typically a licence, and that licence also covers users acting non-commercially.
  • The ordinary hosting exemption, now in Article 6 of the Digital Services Act, does not apply to that situation.

The Digital Services Act expressly leaves EU copyright rules untouched, so Article 17 sits alongside your DSA duties rather than being replaced by them. For the general hosting rules, see our guide to the DSA hosting liability exemption.

Are you an online content-sharing service provider?

The definition in Article 2(6) has four elements. A service is an OCSSP if:

  1. its main purpose, or one of its main purposes, is to store and give the public access to
  2. a large amount of copyright-protected works or other subject matter
  3. uploaded by its users,
  4. which it organises and promotes for profit-making purposes.

Excluded services include non-profit online encyclopaedias, educational and scientific repositories, open-source software platforms, online marketplaces, business-to-business cloud services and cloud storage for users' own use.

Type of siteLikely OCSSP?Why
Ad-funded tube site with user uploadsVery likelyLarge volume of works, organised by category and tags, monetised through ads
Fan or creator platform where creators upload their own workOften yesUsers upload works and the platform promotes them for profit; licensing is usually by contract with the creator
Paysite publishing only its own licensed studio contentNoNo user uploads; you are the publisher and need licences anyway
Small forum with occasional image postsUnlikelyStoring works is not a main purpose and the volume is small
Private cloud storage for customersNoExpressly excluded

"Large amount" is not defined numerically, and national laws and courts may approach it differently. If you are near the line, take advice in the countries you target.

Under Article 17(4), an OCSSP that has no licence for an upload is liable unless it can show it has:

  1. made best efforts to obtain an authorisation from rights holders;
  2. made best efforts, in line with high industry standards of professional diligence, to ensure the unavailability of specific works for which rights holders have given it the relevant and necessary information; and
  3. acted expeditiously on a sufficiently substantiated notice to remove or disable the work, and made best efforts to prevent its future upload.

Article 17(5) says what counts as "best efforts" depends on the type, audience and size of the service, the kinds of works uploaded and the availability and cost of suitable tools. A large tube network is held to a higher standard than a niche start-up.

What best efforts looks like in practice

  • Licensing: a content partner or revenue-share programme for studios and creators, with a clear way for rights holders to approach you. Keep records of approaches you made and responses.
  • Reference files: accept fingerprints or hashes from rights holders and match new uploads against them.
  • Verified uploaders: restricting uploads to verified accounts reduces both copyright and legal risk; many adult platforms already require this under card-scheme rules.
  • Stay-down: once a work has been validly notified, block re-uploads of the same file.

Upload filters in the EU and user safeguards

Article 17 does not use the word "filter", but the duty to keep notified works off a large platform is hard to meet without automated content recognition. The directive balances that with safeguards:

  • Article 17(7): co-operation must not prevent lawful uploads, and users must be able to rely on quotation, criticism, review, caricature, parody and pastiche.
  • Article 17(8): no general monitoring obligation.
  • Article 17(9): an effective and expeditious complaint and redress mechanism, with decisions to remove subject to human review, and access to out-of-court dispute settlement.

In Poland v Parliament and Council (Case C-401/19), the Court of Justice upheld Article 17 in April 2022, but stressed that filters must be able to distinguish lawful from unlawful content. The Commission's 2021 guidance takes the view that automatic blocking should generally be limited to uploads that are manifestly infringing. For adult platforms, the exceptions rarely save a full re-upload of a commercial scene, but they matter for review, commentary and compilation content.

Lighter rules for new and small services

Article 17(6) gives a partial exemption to services that have been available in the EU for less than three years and have an annual turnover below €10 million. They only need to make best efforts to obtain a licence and act expeditiously on notices. If their average monthly unique visitors exceed five million, they must also make best efforts to prevent re-uploads of notified works.

Worked example (hypothetical): a tube site launched in the EU 18 months ago, with €2 million turnover and 3 million monthly unique visitors, needs a licensing route and fast notice-and-takedown, but is not yet expected to run full stay-down matching. Once it passes its third anniversary, the full Article 17(4) duties apply.

How national implementations differ

Because Article 17 is in a directive, each Member State wrote its own version and details vary.

  • Germany implemented it through the UrhDaG, in force since 1 August 2021. It introduced "presumably permitted" minor uses (for example up to 15 seconds of film or audio, 160 characters of text, or 125 kilobytes per photo, when combined with other content) and a pre-flagging option for users.
  • France transposed it by ordinance in 2021, with a role for the audiovisual regulator, now Arcom.
  • Italy transposed it by legislative decree in 2021, giving AGCOM a role in disputes.

The UK left the EU before the transposition deadline and did not implement Article 17. UK-only services rely on the existing hosting defence and must act on notices; see our guide on responding to DMCA and copyright takedown notices.

Frequently asked questions

Does Article 17 apply to a site based outside the EU?

It applies to services offered in EU Member States. A UK or US-based tube site with substantial EU traffic should assume national Article 17 laws can be enforced against it in those countries.

Is Article 17 the same as the AVMSD video-sharing rules?

No. Article 17 is about copyright. The Audiovisual Media Services Directive sets protection duties for video-sharing platforms, such as protecting minors. Many tube sites are subject to both; see our AVMSD guide for video-sharing platforms.

Do I need a fingerprinting vendor?

Not automatically. What is proportionate depends on your size and the tools available. A small platform may manage with hash matching and fast takedowns; a large one will struggle to show best efforts without content recognition.

Next steps

Decide honestly whether your service is an OCSSP, document your licensing efforts and build your notice and stay-down process. If you are planning a new video site, our guide to starting a tube site covers the business side, and the content providers directory lists licensed content sources. More platform rules are in our laws and regulations hub.