The DMCC Act fake reviews ban makes it automatically unlawful in the UK to write, commission or publish fake reviews, to hide that a review was incentivised, or to present reviews in a misleading way. It also puts a positive duty on any business that publishes consumer reviews to take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove banned reviews. These rules have applied since 6 April 2025, and the CMA can fine businesses up to 10% of global turnover for breaches.

For affiliates, review sites, creators and adult platforms that show user ratings, this is not a niche issue: review content is often the core of the business. Here is what the ban covers, what the CMA expects you to do, and how incentivised reviews can still be used legally.

General information, not legal advice. Take advice on your specific review processes.

What the DMCC Act fake reviews ban says

The ban sits in paragraph 13 of Schedule 20 to the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, the list of commercial practices that are unfair in all circumstances. Because these are blacklisted, the CMA does not need to show that consumers were actually misled. Four practices are banned:

  1. Submitting or commissioning fake or concealed incentivised reviews. This covers writing them yourself, asking staff, friends or agencies to write them, and paying for them.
  2. Publishing reviews or review information in a misleading way. For example, suppressing negative reviews, mixing reviews of different products, or showing an average rating that ignores reviews you did not like.
  3. Publishing reviews without reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove fake reviews, concealed incentivised reviews and false or misleading review information.
  4. Offering or advertising services to traders to do any of the above, such as review-writing or rating-boosting services.

Key definitions

  • Fake consumer review: a review that purports to be, but is not, based on a person's genuine experience of the product or trader.
  • Concealed incentivised review: a review where someone was commissioned or rewarded to write it (or to write it a particular way), and that fact is not clear from the review.
  • Consumer review: broadly any review or rating of a product or trader, including star ratings without text.

Fake reviews law in the UK: what changed in 2025

Fake reviews were already risky under the old Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations, but the DMCC Act changed three things:

  • A specific ban. Fake and concealed incentivised reviews are named on the blacklist, so there is less room for argument.
  • A positive duty on publishers. Having no process is itself a breach if you publish reviews.
  • Direct fines. The CMA can now decide breaches itself and impose penalties of up to 10% of global turnover, or £300,000 for individuals, without going to court. See CMA fining powers under the DMCC Act.

The CMA gave businesses a three-month grace period after commencement to get compliant, then moved to enforcement. In March 2026 it opened investigations into five businesses' review practices, covering suppression of negative reviews, incentivised positive reviews and inflated average ratings. The CMA said it expected to give an update in September 2026; no outcomes had been announced at the time of writing.

Incentivised reviews rules: when rewards are allowed

Incentivised reviews are not banned outright. What is banned is concealing the incentive. The CMA's fake reviews guidance (CMA208) treats incentives broadly: cash, discounts, free products, entry into prize draws, loyalty points or other benefits, offered before or after the review.

ScenarioAllowed?What to do
Offering a discount to anyone who leaves a review, positive or negativeYes, with disclosureLabel each resulting review as incentivised.
Offering a reward only for positive reviewsNoConditioning the reward on sentiment makes the review misleading.
Sending free products to creators for honest reviewsYes, with disclosureEach review must say the product was free; if there is any brand control, label as an ad.
Staff or family reviewing your productsRiskyDisclose the connection clearly or do not publish.
Buying reviews from a review-writing serviceNoBanned for buyer and seller.

Affiliates writing "reviews" of products they earn commission on are in a similar position. A commission-earning review is not a consumer review in the paragraph 13 sense, but it is advertising and must be labelled. See UK affiliate disclosure requirements.

Review moderation obligations for publishers

If your site, app or platform publishes reviews written by others (user ratings on a cam directory, comments on a creator review site, star ratings in a comparison table), you are a review publisher. The CMA guidance sets out what reasonable and proportionate steps look like, scaled to the size of the business and the risk:

  • A written policy explaining what reviews are banned, how incentivised reviews are handled and how users can report suspicious reviews.
  • A risk assessment of how fake reviews could reach your site, reviewed regularly.
  • Proactive detection, for example limiting reviews to verified customers, spotting unusual patterns (bursts of five-star reviews, repeated phrasing, shared IPs) and checking reviewer histories.
  • Removal and sanctions: a process to take down banned reviews quickly and act against repeat offenders.
  • Accurate aggregation: averages and rankings must not be distorted by suppressed or suspicious reviews.
  • Evaluation: test whether your measures actually work.

Larger platforms are expected to do more. In 2025, following investigations begun under the old law, both Google and Amazon gave formal undertakings to the CMA committing to tougher detection and sanctions, which give a sense of what "good" looks like at scale.

Small site, real duty. A hypothetical adult review site with 300 user reviews a month does not need machine learning, but it does need a written policy, a reporting button, a simple check for verified sign-ups, and a log of what it removed and why.

What this means for affiliates and creators

  • Do not seed your own reviews on programme pages, app stores or forums. Posting as a "satisfied customer" when you earn commission is both a fake review and a breach of the ban on falsely presenting yourself as a consumer.
  • Check your traffic sources. Buying "review" placements or ratings from a vendor exposes you even if the vendor wrote them.
  • Be careful with testimonial widgets. If you display ratings pulled from a programme or third-party feed, you are publishing them. Check where they come from.
  • Creators offering fans rewards for reviews or ratings must not limit rewards to positive ones and must disclose them.

For building honest review content that also ranks, see affiliate reviews that rank and how to build an adult review site.

A five-step compliance plan

  1. Map every place reviews appear: on-site user reviews, imported star ratings, testimonials, social proof widgets, app store listings you control.
  2. Identify incentives: any discounts, free products, prize draws or affiliate arrangements connected to those reviews, and add disclosure where they exist.
  3. Write the policy and publish it where reviewers and readers can find it.
  4. Put basic controls in place: verified-customer flags, a report button, pattern checks and a removal log.
  5. Review quarterly, and again whenever the CMA publishes a decision on review practices.

Frequently asked questions

Does the EU have the same rules?

Broadly. Since May 2022 the EU Unfair Commercial Practices Directive has blacklisted fake reviews and claims that reviews are genuine without reasonable checks, and businesses that give access to reviews must explain whether and how they verify them. See affiliate disclosure rules in the EU.

Can I delete negative reviews?

You can remove reviews that break a clear, consistently applied policy (abuse, spam, irrelevant content). Removing genuine negative reviews to improve your rating is publishing reviews in a misleading way and is banned.

Are AI-written reviews fake reviews?

If an AI-generated review purports to be based on a real person's genuine experience and is not, it is a fake review. Using AI to help a genuine customer phrase their own experience is different, but generating reviews at scale is squarely within the ban.

Next steps

Write or update your review policy this month, then check any comparison tables or rankings against comparison website rules. For more guides on claims and promotions, browse the advertising rules section.