In a flat fee vs commission affiliate deal, the question is who carries the performance risk. With commission (CPA, revshare or CPL) you are paid only when your traffic converts, so you carry the risk. With a flat fee, or a tenancy deal, the advertiser pays a fixed amount for a placement over a set period, whatever it produces, so they carry it. Hybrid deals combine a smaller fee with commission. The right price for a flat fee starts with what the placement already earns you on commission, plus a premium for the certainty you are giving the advertiser.

Flat-fee deals are common on established review sites, directories, high-traffic blogs and tube or content sites with predictable inventory.

Flat fee vs commission: tenancy and hybrid deals explained

Deal typeHow it worksBest for
Commission onlyCPA, revshare or CPL on tracked conversionsNew relationships, unproven placements
Fixed fee placementOne-off or monthly fee for a banner, listing, link or articleStable traffic, brand awareness campaigns
Tenancy dealAdvertiser "rents" a defined position (for example the top slot on a comparison page) for a fixed termHigh-value, high-intent positions
Hybrid (fee plus commission)Lower fixed fee plus a reduced or standard commissionSharing risk when both sides want upside
Guaranteed minimumCommission, but topped up to an agreed minimum if earnings fall shortCommission deals with downside protection

A tenancy deal affiliate sites sell is often priced monthly and renewed by agreement. The term "tenancy" is most common in iGaming and finance, but the model is used across verticals.

Why publishers like flat fees

  • Predictable income, useful for cash flow and planning.
  • No exposure to the advertiser's conversion rate, scrubs or tracking problems.
  • Monetises brand-awareness value that never shows up as tracked conversions.

Why publishers stay on commission

  • Upside: a strong month or a viral page earns more.
  • Revshare builds a long-term income tail; flat fees end when the term ends.
  • Easier to get started; advertisers rarely pay fixed fees for unproven inventory.

Advertisers, for their part, prefer commission because they pay only for results. They accept flat fees when the placement is valuable, scarce or carries brand prestige, and when they have data showing it converts.

How to price a banner placement or listing

Start from your own data, not a rate card you found elsewhere. You need:

  • Impressions of the placement per month (from your analytics or ad server).
  • Click-through rate on the placement.
  • Earnings per click (EPC) from the affiliate offers you have run there.

From these, work out the placement's effective eCPM: earnings per 1,000 impressions. Our guides to how to calculate eCPM and how to calculate EPC show the formulas.

Worked example (hypothetical)

  1. The header banner on your review site serves 200,000 impressions a month.
  2. It averages a 0.4% click-through rate: 800 clicks.
  3. Your best-performing offer there has an EPC of €0.50: 800 × €0.50 = €400 a month, an eCPM of €2.00.
  4. That €400 is your floor: accepting less means losing money compared with running the affiliate offer.
  5. Add a premium, because you are giving up the upside of a strong month and handing the advertiser guaranteed exposure. The size is a judgement call that depends on how stable your figures are; in this example, a 20–50% premium gives a range of roughly €480–€600.
  6. Adjust for exclusivity (no competitor on the page), seasonality and contract length.

Use a few months of data. Price from a three-to-six-month average, not your best month. If traffic is volatile, offer a shorter term or a hybrid rather than a large fixed fee you may not be able to justify at renewal.

Pricing a tenancy position

Top slots on comparison pages are worth more than their click share suggests, because they influence how readers view every other listing. To price one:

  • Measure what the slot earns on commission today, and compare it with lower slots. The gap is the premium of the position.
  • Consider what the second-best advertiser would pay for the same slot. Tenancy is ultimately priced by competition.
  • Agree what the tenant gets: position, logo, copy, review length, bonus code, and whether you can still rank other brands honestly.
  • Set a review date so the price reflects traffic changes.

When a hybrid deal makes sense

A hybrid of a smaller fixed fee plus commission suits placements with solid but uncertain performance. You get a guaranteed base; the advertiser pays less up front and keeps an incentive for you to send quality traffic.

Hypothetical example. Instead of €550 flat, you agree €250 a month plus the standard CPA. If the placement keeps converting as before, you earn about €650; in a weak month, you still have the €250.

Contract points to agree

  • Exact placement, size, pages and devices included.
  • Term, renewal, notice period and payment timing (ideally in advance).
  • Impression or traffic guarantees, if any, and what happens if you fall short.
  • Whether affiliate tracking still applies, so both sides can measure performance.
  • Content and creative approval, and your right to refuse misleading creatives.
  • Exclusivity, if offered; see exclusive affiliate deals.

Label paid placements clearly

A fixed-fee listing is advertising. In the UK, the CAP Code requires marketing communications to be obviously identifiable as such, and EU consumer law treats hidden paid ranking as misleading. If a brand pays for the top slot, say so clearly near the listing. See labelling advertorials and native ads.

Frequently asked questions

Is a flat fee better than commission?

Not automatically. A flat fee priced below what the placement earns on commission is a bad deal. It is better when it reflects your real earnings plus a fair risk premium.

Can I charge a flat fee with little traffic?

It is hard. Advertisers buy fixed placements for proven reach or a valuable niche audience. Build a performance record on commission first.

Should I still track clicks on a flat-fee placement?

Yes. Tracking shows both sides what the placement delivers and gives you the evidence to renew at the same or a higher price.

Next steps

Pull three to six months of impressions, CTR and EPC for each placement and calculate its floor price before you take any offer. For context on balancing ad and affiliate income, read affiliate links vs display ads, and see who buys placements in the traffic sources directory.