Affiliate shaving is when a program deliberately under-reports the conversions, sign-ups or revenue you referred, so it pays you less commission than you earned. It can take the form of missing sales, revshare customers re-attributed to the house, or a fixed share of leads quietly marked invalid. You spot it by comparing the program's figures against your own independent tracking over a meaningful sample and looking for gaps that ordinary tracking loss cannot explain.

Shaving is a real risk in performance marketing, but not every drop in numbers is shaving. Cookie loss, ad blockers, cross-device journeys, fraud scrubs and genuine changes in traffic quality all produce similar symptoms. The aim is to rule those out first, then decide what to do with the evidence you have.

How affiliate shaving works

Affiliate program shaving conversions does not need sophisticated technology. Common mechanisms include:

  • Dropping a percentage of conversions before they reach your stats, for example not firing the postback on every nth sale.
  • Re-attributing customers to direct, house or another partner, often justified by a later click or a coupon code.
  • Over-scrubbing leads, marking valid sign-ups as duplicates or fraud beyond what the terms allow.
  • Under-reporting revshare revenue, for example by showing net revenue after undisclosed deductions or moving spend to an unattributed account.
  • Delaying rebills or failing to credit recurring payments on subscription offers.

Some of these can also happen through honest errors: a broken integration, a misconfigured postback or a platform migration. That is why evidence matters more than suspicion.

Signs of shaving to look for

Individually, none of these proves anything. Several together, persisting over weeks, deserve a closer look.

  1. Conversion rate falls while everything else is stable. Same placements, same GEOs, same click volume, same landing pages, but conversions drop noticeably and stay down.
  2. Volume flattens at a suspicious level. Conversions never seem to exceed a round number, or rarely cross the threshold for a higher tier.
  3. The gap widens as you grow. Your tracker and the program agree on small volumes but diverge as you scale.
  4. Revshare players stop spending in bulk. A cohort's reported revenue falls sharply in a way that does not match the program's general trends or other programs' data.
  5. Other programs behave normally. The same traffic sent to a comparable offer converts as expected.
  6. Explanations change. The program cannot give a consistent, specific reason for the discrepancy.

Rule out the ordinary first: check for tracking changes on your side, browser updates affecting cookies, new ad-blocker rules, and changes to the program's landing page or checkout. Our guide to tracking discrepancies lists the usual culprits.

How to test with your own tracking

You cannot prove shaved affiliate stats from the program's dashboard alone. You need a second, independent record.

1. Track every click yourself

Route links through your own tracker or a redirect that logs click ID, timestamp, sub-ID, GEO and device. This is your baseline. If you need a tool, compare options in the affiliate tracking platforms directory.

2. Use server-to-server postbacks

Ask the program to fire a postback to your tracker for every conversion, passing your click ID back. Then you can match conversions to clicks, and spot conversions shown in their dashboard that never reached you, or vice versa.

3. Run a controlled comparison

Split the same traffic evenly between the suspect program and a trusted comparable offer for two to four weeks. Keep landing pages, placements and timing identical. If conversion rates differ far beyond what normal variation would explain, you have a meaningful signal.

4. Make test conversions

Where the terms allow it, complete a small number of genuine test sign-ups or purchases through your links, noting the time, click ID and any confirmation emails. Check whether each appears in your stats. Never generate fake or incentivised conversions: that is fraud in its own right and will breach your terms.

5. Check sample size

Ten conversions is noise. You need enough volume for differences to be reliable, typically hundreds of clicks and dozens of conversions per variant, more for low-converting offers.

A worked example (hypothetical)

Suppose you send 10,000 clicks a month to Program A and historically see a 2% conversion rate, about 200 sales. Over three months, reported sales fall to 140 a month while your tracker still logs 10,000 clicks with the same sources. You split traffic 50/50 with Program B, a similar offer: B converts at 1.9% on its half, A at 1.4%. Your postback logs show 30 click IDs where your test purchases completed but never appeared in A's stats.

That is not legal proof, but it is a strong, documented case to put to the program.

What to do if you suspect shaving

  1. Gather your evidence in a short, factual summary: dates, click and conversion counts from both sources, the comparison test, and specific click IDs.
  2. Raise it privately and neutrally with your affiliate manager. Ask them to investigate specific transactions rather than accusing them of shaving. Honest errors are fixed fastest this way.
  3. Request a reconciliation of the missing conversions and back-payment if the investigation finds a fault.
  4. Check your agreement for audit rights, dispute procedures and notice periods. Our guide to affiliate agreement contract clauses explains what to look for.
  5. Reduce exposure while you wait: move most traffic to alternatives and keep a small test stream running so you can see whether numbers recover.
  6. Escalate if needed. If the program is on a network, the network may mediate. For significant sums, take legal advice on a contract claim.

Be careful about public accusations. Posting unproven claims about a named company on forums or social media can expose you to defamation risk. Stick to verifiable facts about your own experience.

How to protect yourself in future

  • Insist on postback tracking and click-level reporting before sending serious volume.
  • Diversify across several programs so one bad partner cannot sink a month.
  • Prefer programs with transparent player-level revshare reports, published scrub rules and clear terms on negative carryover.
  • Review reversal patterns monthly, as covered in commission holds and reversals.

Frequently asked questions

How common is affiliate shaving?

There is no reliable public data on how often it happens, so treat any figures you see quoted with caution. What is certain is that it is discussed widely in the industry, which is why independent tracking is standard practice.

How do I prove shaving?

You usually cannot prove intent, but you can prove a discrepancy. Matched click IDs, postback logs, controlled split tests and documented test conversions make a case that a program must answer.

Is a sudden commission cut the same as shaving?

No. A disclosed change to rates is a commercial decision, not shaving. See what to do when a program cuts your commission.

Next steps

Set up independent click and postback tracking on every program you promote, then review the gaps monthly. For more on payout structures and their risks, browse our commission models guides.